Why do you keep sending me 20%-off sale emails?
My initial introduction to your brand came via Seth Godin, in his book Purple Cow. And I’ve seen your product on Seth’s feet when I’m lucky enough to attend a conference where he’s speaking. One of my co-workers finally pushed me over the edge into becoming your customer, however, when he mentioned a great gifting strategy for one of his nieces involving your socks. Basically, he mails one sock at a time, because, as he writes his niece, he can’t quite remember how many feet this girl has. One foot or many, many feet, he’ll figure it out one crazy mismatched sock at a time.
I placed my initial order for just one pair of socks, and was happy to also receive a bonus pair of socks as a new email-subscriber bonus. What really wowed me, however, was receiving a shipping confirmation email a few mere HOURS after placing my order. Maybe two days later, I was digging the socks out of my mailbox, and the next day at the office, I was surreptitiously sporting some dress code rebellion.
At this point, I was completely and totally in love with the LittleMissMatched.com operation. I wasn’t filling out and returning the sock forms with my own unique designs for your consideration, but I was spending way too much time on your website browsing socks and wishing that you’d come out with some with a brown base-color and abstract design soon.
On the day I made my first (and so far only) purchase with you, I opted into your email list. I’m an email marketer myself (in my time selling jewelry, gourmet popcorn, and car tires), and I was excitedly anticipating the wonders that would grace my inbox. I mean, you have a great product and a jaw-droppignly remarkable fulfillment operation. Surely your email marketing would be equally awesome.
First post-order email: “Introducing 5 New Limited Edition Sock Styles!”
Awesome. Exactly the content I was hoping for.
Second email: “Spend $50, Get $10 OFF for 2 Days Only!”
Um, really? I just had an amazing experience with your organization, and I’m perfectly happy to pay full price plus shipping right now.
Third email: “Spend $50, Get $10 OFF: Ends Today!”
Oh no. See above. And if you really have to give something away, why not shipping? $5.95 seems a little steep for socks that you flat-pack and ship via the U.S. Postal Service, now that you have me thinking about discounting.
Fourth email: Online Only: 20% Off All New Bags 2 Days Only!
You have bags? I didn’t know that. The 20% off turns me off though. I’d much rather you have focused on one of your bags and why I, as an adult woman (not a girl), would care to buy one. “Stuffy office dress code! Rebel with one of our zany yet practical bags!” Then tell me why the bag is just an awesome bag that’ll meet my practical needs (if not exceed them), in addition to looking wonderfully MissMatched.
Fifth Email: 25% Off All Liner Socks – 2 Days Only!
Sixth Email: Last Day: 25% Off All Liner Socks!
And so it goes on. Of the 12 marketing emails I’ve received since my purchase with you, 8 are about sales events. And my enthusiasm for your brand has died a little bit more with each email that offers me new ways to SAVE!
I wear my Little Miss Matched socks with joy. They’re my must-have accessory on days with air travel and for doctor appointments that require you to strip down to nothing but your socks and a paper gown. But I no longer think of your brand as innovative and exciting. Instead, you’re just one more retailer who gives away margin in place of offering remarkable marketing content. And that makes me really sad.
I’m sure there’s a part of your email list that is sale- and savings-driven. And nothing increases email open and click rates like a good sale. (I know. I do this for a living, too.) But there’s also a portion of your list that just wants to cheer on and support a remarkable brand and be romanced over and over again with how awesome you are.
So, please, for my sake if not yours, stop sending me sale emails. If price really mattered, I’d be buying my socks from Wal-Mart and mixing them up myself.
Sincerely,
Deborah Krier
P.S. Need a new remarkable idea? Announce your new line of fair labor socks in special, limited edition Little Miss Matched designs. Three times the price but look at all the good each purchase enables. In other words, keep being remarkable.